Sermon Notes:

Series: Is It Ok to Doubt God?

September 27, 2026: "Where is the Evidence?"

By: Pastor Joel Philbrook


Consider this...


Gideon’s story reminds us that doubt isn’t a sign that something is wrong with us; it’s often a sign that something is growing in us. Gideon wasn’t a spiritual superhero; he was insecure, afraid, and constantly looking for evidence that God was actually with him. He poked God with a stick again and again, asking for proof, and God didn’t shame him for it. Instead, God worked with him. God met Gideon in the winepress, not on the mountaintop. He called Gideon a “mighty warrior” long before Gideon ever acted like one. Maybe the evidence we’re looking for isn’t found in God removing our fear, but in God staying with us through it. Maybe the unanswered prayers aren’t God ignoring us; they’re God maturing us.


Gideon’s need for proof didn’t make him strong; God’s patience did. The thinning of the army didn’t make Gideon confident; God’s presence did. And the same is true for us. When life feels like a cave, when prayers seem to bounce off the ceiling, when we’re tempted to think God shows up for everyone else but us, those moments might actually be the soil where real trust begins to grow. God doesn’t wait for us to become mighty warriors before He calls us one. He simply asks us to take one small step of faith, even if doubt is still whispering in the background.

  • Daily Meditation: From Guilt to the Doorway of Faith

    Scripture Focus: "Lord, I believe; help my unbelief!" — Mark 9:24


    Reflection: So many of us carry the hidden weight of unvoiced questions. We sit in pews or walk through daily life performing certainty, terrified that if anyone saw our lingering doubts, we would be labeled spiritually weak or unfaithful. But God does not demand performance; He desires presence. When life hits hard, when expectations shatter, circumstances overpower us, or sheer exhaustion sets in, doubt is not a sign that our faith has died. It is a sign that our human understanding has reached its limit, inviting us to rely on something deeper than ourselves.


    Think of Sarah laughing in the tent, Gideon testing his fleece in fear, or Elijah collapsing under the broom bush in complete burnout. God did not meet any of them with immediate condemnation or rejection. Instead, He offered patience, strength, and gentle care. 

    Your doubts do not scare God, nor do they diminish His faithfulness to you. When you stop treating doubt as a moral failure and begin seeing it as an invitation, your questions become the very doorway where you encounter the real, living God—not as a rigid judge, but as a tender, enduring Savior.


    Prayer: Lord, I release the pressure to have everything figured out. Forgive me for the times I have buried my questions in shame or traded honest trust for rigid performance. Thank you that my doubts cannot break Your promises and my weakness cannot exhaust Your grace. Take my unvoiced questions today and open my eyes to see Your gentle presence right here in the middle of them. Amen.




  • Where are you protecting your heart? Is there a promise, prayer, or area of your life where you've adopted cynicism or quiet doubt simply to protect yourself from future disappointment?


  • Trust vs. Certainty: In what ways have you been demanding complete certainty from God rather than walking in relational trust with Him? What would it look like to release the need for a solved equation and lean into a living Savior?


  • Bringing your "laughter" into the light: God saw Sarah behind the tent, named her doubt, and offered an invitation: "Is anything too hard for the Lord?" What hidden doubt or whispered question do you need to bring out of hiding and lay before Him today?

  • Creative Ways to Worship Through the Arts

    Art provides a safe, non-verbal space to process heavy emotions, unburden unspoken anxieties, and move from self-protective cynicism into honest communion with God.


    • Visual Art: "The Tent Door" Canvas (Visualizing Sarah's Story)

      • The Practice: Take a canvas or piece of paper and divide it visually into two halves. On the left side, paint or draw using dark tones, harsh strokes, or words that represent your "behind-the-tent" doubts—the things that feel impossible, dead, or past their expiration date. On the right side, paint simple light or warm colors representing God's promised presence over those exact spaces.

      • The Worship: As you blend the boundary line between the two sides, pray for God to meet your quiet cynicism with His patient faithfulness, transforming your hidden doubt into visual praise.

    • Creative Writing & Poetry: "Lament and Answer" Journaling (Gideon & Elijah)

      • The Practice: Write a two-part poem or letter. Part one is raw, unfiltered honesty: tell God exactly where you feel exhausted, under-resourced, or disappointed by your circumstances (much like Elijah under the broom tree). Write down every "Why?" and "How long?".

      • The Worship: Pause, take a slow breath, and write part two by listening for His character in Scripture. Write down the attributes of God that speak over those exact fears—His strength made perfect in weakness, His gift of rest, and His quiet voice.

    • Musical/Auditory Processing: A Playlist of Tension & Trust

      • The Practice: Build a two-part playlist. The first half consists of songs featuring honest lament, questioning, and raw human struggle (such as biblical Psalm adaptations or acoustic laments). The second half shifts slowly toward declarations of God’s unshakeable nature and eternal faithfulness.

      • The Worship: Listen intentionally in a quiet space without distractions. Allow the musical shift from lament to hope to move your heart physically and emotionally from self-reliance into rest.

    • Tactile Worship: The Stone & Water Exercise (Gideon’s Fleece)

      • The Practice: Collect a small stone or piece of fabric. Hold it tightly in your hand during your prayer time as a physical symbol of the burden, circumstance, or weakness you are trying to control or double-check out of fear.

      • The Worship: Slowly submerge the stone or fabric in a bowl of water, releasing your grip completely. As you leave it at the bottom of the bowl, declare out loud that you are releasing your need for total certainty and choosing to rest in God's sovereign care.

  • If you would like to ask a question about what you are experiencing or learning, we would love to help you. Give us your question below, and one of our pastoral staff will get back to you. 


    ASK YOUR QUESTION

What's Coming Next in our teaching series called "Is It Ok To Doubt God?"

Many of us have been told or simply felt that having questions about God is somehow sinful. We worry that if we doubt, we are failing at faith. We’ve been led to believe that "unquestionable faith" is the only way to follow Jesus. But does God really demand that we never ask "Why" or "How?" If we have those lingering questions, are we doing something wrong? Is it actually okay to doubt God?

When we view doubt as a sin, it often leads to deep guilt or even fear. Then, when life hits hard, when we feel let down, when we crave more evidence, or when a crisis shatters our world, doubt becomes our natural response. In those moments, what do we do? Is God angry with us?

Thankfully, we aren't the first to wrestle with these questions. We are surrounded by a "cloud of witnesses" who navigated the tension of faith and doubt long before us. By looking at their stories, we gain a fresh perspective on how God actually views our uncertainty. We’ll discover that doubt visited even the greatest heroes of the Bible, and more importantly, we’ll see how God responded to them with deep love, wonderful grace, and a beautiful, patient understanding.

In this three-week series, we explore the tension between our human expectations and God’s divine reality through three iconic figures who dared to doubt. We begin with Sarah by addressing the Doubt of Impossibility, seeing how God’s sovereignty overrules our human expiration dates. Next, we look at Gideon and tackle the Doubt of Circumstance, learning how God uses our perceived weaknesses to display His strength. Finally, we conclude with Elijah by examining the Doubt of Exhaustion, discovering how God meets our deepest burnout with gentle nurture rather than condemnation.

Together, these stories remind us that doubt isn’t the end of faith. Instead, it is a doorway to a deeper, more honest relationship with a God who is big enough to handle every one of our questions.



  • Join us for...

    Week 1: 9/20 "Expiring Promises" by Pastor Joel Philbrook

    Week 2:  9/27 "Where is the Evidence"  by Pastor Joel Philbrook

    Week 3:  10/4 "The Exhausted Doubter" by Pastor Joel Philbrook


Catch up on previous sermons


SEE THE LATEST LIVESTREAM VIDEOs ON YouTube


Listen to SUNDAY MESSAGES below or IN APPLE podcasTS


LOADING PLAYER…